This page is for the people who decide whether a public entity's case settles or goes to trial: claims managers, litigation managers and executive directors at risk pools and JPAs, and the panel defense counsel on each case.
Why the county matters
A jury is drawn from the people who live in that county. They read the same local news. They drive the same roads, send their children to the same schools, and have their own history with the local police. When the defendant is their own city or county, those experiences come into the jury room with them.
Two counties next to each other can see the same claim in different ways. Jurors in one place may see a claim against a town, a school or a police officer one way. Jurors one county over may see it another way.
Risk managers have said this for years. A 2016 PRIMA conference session on settle-or-try decisions told public entities to know "the public's attitude toward their local government as those people are your jury pool" (Safety National's notes on the session). The Michigan Municipal League's pool asks the same thing in its settle-or-try factors: "What is the likely attitude of the jurors?"
What shapes how local jurors see a public defendant?
- Their view of local government. Some jurors trust the city or county. Others come in doubting it.
- Local events. A recent news story about the police, a school or a road can stay on jurors' minds.
- The kind of claim. Jurors may react to a police case very differently from a fall on a sidewalk.
- The people in the case. How jurors see the officer, the employee or the driver, and the person who was hurt.
- The record. What the documents and testimony actually show, and how clearly counsel can tell that story.
How this plays out by type of case
Police and civil rights cases
Force, arrest and jail cases often turn on how jurors see local police and the city behind them. That view can vary a great deal from one county to the next.
Employment cases
When a city, county or school worker sues, jurors weigh the employer's side against the worker's story. Many jurors are workers themselves, and some may picture their own boss.
Premises cases
Falls on sidewalks, roads, parks and public buildings often turn on what the city or county knew and when it knew it. Jurors there may also think about the roads and parks they use every day.
Auto cases
Crashes with police cars, buses, plows and other public vehicles bring in how jurors see the driver, the agency and the injury.
How a pool can find out before it settles
No one can promise what a jury will do. A pool can still learn a lot before it sets settlement authority:
- Look at past verdicts in that county on similar claims, from public court records and local news.
- Ask defense counsel what they have seen from juries in that courthouse.
- Use jury research, such as a focus group or a mock trial, on the biggest cases. What mock jury research looks like for a public entity.
VerdictLine adds a county jury read to every case a pool sends, small or large. It builds synthetic jurors for the county where the case will be heard. A synthetic juror is a computer-built stand-in for a person who could sit on a jury there. The read shows how those jurors are likely to see the case, and why, with every point cited to the record. Counsel reviews and signs every report. VerdictLine gives no verdict prediction and no dollar figure. See how a county jury read helps before you settle, what it does at each stage of a case, and how we check our reads.
See how your county may see one of your cases
Pick one of your pool's cases from the public record. We will send one page on how a jury in that county is likely to see it, and why. No file is needed and there is no cost. Ask for a free read, or read what VerdictLine is. Weighing a settlement now? Use the settle-or-try checklist.
Questions about county juries
Why does the county matter in a lawsuit against a city?
Jurors come from the county where the case is heard. Their views of local police, roads, schools and government shape how they weigh the facts. The same facts can land very differently in two counties.
Can anyone tell us exactly what a jury will do?
No. No one can promise a verdict. What a pool can get is a read on how jurors in that county are likely to see the case, and why, so it can ask better questions before it settles or tries the case.
How can a pool learn how its county sees these cases?
Look at past verdicts in that county, ask counsel what they have seen there, and use jury research. VerdictLine adds a county jury read on every case, from the day it is filed, cited to the record.
Does VerdictLine give a dollar figure?
No. VerdictLine gives no verdict prediction, no settlement number and no reserve figure. Counsel reviews and signs every report, and the pool and its counsel decide.