Proof: we check our reads against what happened
After a trial, we show how each read compared with what happened at trial. We show the misses too, and why they happened.
Proof
We will post proof here once it is cleared to share. Until then, ask for a free one-page read on one of your own cases and judge the work yourself.
A single verdict is one outcome. That is why we report every case against its outcome, not only the ones that went well.
What a review after the verdict shows
Each main point of the read
In our words, with the date we wrote it.
What happened at trial
On that same question.
Matched or missed
For every point.
For each miss
What the record showed and why the read went the other way.
What the review looks like
The layout below uses a made-up case. It is not a real result.
| Question | Our read before trial sealed Jan 5 | What the jury did | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| How will jurors weigh the late repair of the lights? | As the strongest fact against the city. The repair request came four days before the fall. | Found the city responsible. | ✓ Matched |
| How will jurors see Ms. Doe's own care? | Some may fault her. It was raining and she knew the lot. | Put no fault on Ms. Doe. | ✕ Missed |
| Why we missed: The record showed she wore flat, rubber-soled shoes. Jurors gave that more weight than we did. | |||
Questions about proof
How accurate is VerdictLine?
VerdictLine does not predict verdicts, so there is no hit rate to quote. After each trial, we show how each part of our read compared with what happened at trial, with the date we wrote it, and we show the misses and why they happened. One verdict is one outcome, so each case will be reported, not just the wins.
Do you show where the read was wrong?
Yes. A review after the verdict shows how each main part of the read compared with what happened at trial, and the misses are listed with the reasons.
Is one verdict enough to trust the method?
No. A single verdict is one outcome. Each case we work on will be reported against its outcome, misses included, so the record builds over time.
Can we see proof?
We will post proof here once it is cleared to share. Until then, ask for a free one-page read on one of your own cases and judge the work yourself. We can also walk you through how a review is built on a call.
See our work on one of your cases
Ask for a free one-page read on one case, or talk to us about a case with a date coming.