This page is for public entity risk pools, self-insured cities, counties and schools, JPAs, and the panel defense counsel who handle their cases. It explains what mock jury research is, why it matters more when the defendant is a public body, and how VerdictLine puts a county jury read on every case.
Why is a case against a city or county different?
When a person sues a city, county or school, the defendant is not a neighbor. It is the local government. Jurors bring their own views of that government into the room. They may think about local police, the roads they drive, or the schools their children attend. Those views differ from one county to the next.
That is why the venue matters so much. The same facts can land very differently in two counties. A mock jury drawn from the right county helps a pool see how its own jurors may react, instead of guessing from a case somewhere else.
What kinds of jury research can a pool use?
- Focus group. A small group of local people talks through the case and its themes. Counsel learns what they care about and what confuses them.
- Mock trial. A short version of the trial, with both sides presented, ending in a vote. It tests how a jury may decide.
- Shadow jury. People like the real jury watch the trial and report what they think each day, so counsel can adjust.
- Venue study. A look at how people in that county tend to see this kind of claim.
Done the usual way, each of these uses real people picked to match the local jury pool. Each one takes time to set up, and none of them is cheap.
Risk managers use them for a reason. A 2016 PRIMA conference session on settle-or-try decisions put it plainly: "A mock jury can teach you many things about your verdict potential and the issues the jury may focus on" (Safety National's notes on the session).
Why mock juries are used on only a few cases
Because of the cost and the time, mock juries usually come in late, close to trial, and only on the biggest cases. The rest of a pool's cases never get a jury view at all. Those cases still settle or go to trial. They just do it without anyone asking how local jurors would see them.
How VerdictLine fits
VerdictLine puts a county jury read on every case, from the day it is filed. It uses synthetic jurors built for the county where the case will be heard. A synthetic juror is a computer-built stand-in for a person who could sit on a jury there. The read shows how those jurors are likely to see the case, and why.
When a case goes to trial, VerdictLine adds one study: a focus group, a venue study or a trial-week shadow jury. Counsel reviews and signs every report. The pool and its counsel make every decision. See what VerdictLine does at each stage, filing to trial.
VerdictLine does not give a verdict or a dollar figure. It gives the pool and its counsel a cited view of how local jurors are likely to see the case, early enough to act on it. After each decision, we put our read beside what happened, misses included: how we check our reads. Records stay the pool's: how we handle your records. See what VerdictLine is and who it is for.
Which cases does this help with?
Common liability cases for public entities: police and civil rights claims, employment claims, premises cases such as falls on sidewalks, roads, parks and buildings, and auto cases with city or county vehicles. Each one can turn on how local jurors see the public defendant. Read how a jury in your county sees a lawsuit against a city or county.
See it on one of your cases
Pick one of your pool's cases from the public record. We will send one page on how a jury in that county is likely to see it, and why. No file is needed and there is no cost. Ask for a free read.
Questions about mock jury research
What is a mock jury for a public entity?
A mock jury is a practice jury. People like the ones who could serve in that county hear a short version of the case and say what they think. For a city, county or school, it shows how local jurors may see a public defendant before the real trial.
What is the difference between a mock trial, a focus group and a shadow jury?
A focus group talks through the case and its themes. A mock trial plays out a short version of the trial and ends with a vote. A shadow jury watches the real trial and reports what it thinks each day. All three use people like the local jury pool.
Why are mock juries used on only a few cases?
Mock juries take time to set up and cost a lot to run, so they are usually saved for a few big trials. VerdictLine puts a county jury read on every case, from the day it is filed, and adds one study when a case goes to trial.
Do synthetic jurors replace real mock jurors?
No. A synthetic juror is a computer-built stand-in for a person who could sit on a jury in that county. It gives a pool an early read on every case, between full studies. A pool can still run a mock jury with real people on its biggest trials.
Do you hire people to sit on mock juries?
No. This page is for risk pools and their defense counsel. We do not recruit or pay mock jurors.