Before mediation, someone at the pool has to set settlement authority. That means a choice: settle now, or be ready to try the case. There is no formula. But the same questions come up on almost every case. Here is a plain checklist a claims or litigation manager can use with counsel.
The settle-or-try checklist
- What could a trial cost? Think about the range a jury might award, plus defense fees, expert fees and staff time through trial.
- How will a judge and jury see what happened? Are there facts that could make jurors angry at the city, county or school?
- How bad are the injuries? Some injuries raise juror sympathy no matter who was at fault.
- How will the people come across? Is the plaintiff likeable? Are your own witnesses clear and believable? Who is the plaintiff's lawyer?
- How do jurors in that county see local government? The people who sit on the jury live there. What they think of the town, the police or the schools comes into the room with them.
- What does the record support on each claim? Which key facts are proven, and which are still open?
- What else is at stake for the member? News coverage, other cases like this one, and whether a verdict could go past your coverage limits.
These questions are not ours alone. The Michigan Municipal League's pool lists the same kinds of factors in its guide to deciding whether to settle or try a case, including "What is the likely attitude of the jurors?" A 2016 PRIMA conference session made the same point about venue: you need to know how the public sees its local government, because "those people are your jury pool" (Safety National's notes on the session).
Which questions are hardest to answer?
Most of the list comes from the file: the bills, the record and counsel's report. Questions 2 and 5 are harder. They ask how people in one county are likely to see this case, and counsel's experience may come from other courts. That is where a look at the local jury helps.
Questions to ask counsel before mediation
- Does your evaluation match how jurors in that county are likely to see the case?
- Which facts will jurors there weigh most, and are they in the record?
- If we went to trial, what would worry you most?
Where VerdictLine fits
VerdictLine helps with questions 2, 5 and 6. It shows how a jury in that county is likely to see the case, and what the record supports on each claim, cited to the page. It gives no settlement number and no reserve figure, and it makes no decisions. Counsel reviews and signs every report. If that would help on a case, you can get a county jury read before you settle.
How to try one
Start with one case that has a decision coming, such as a mediation or a request for settlement authority. To see our work first, ask for a free one-page read on that case. You pick a case from the public record. No file is needed and there is no cost.
Common questions
Is there one right answer to settle or try?
No. Each case is weighed on its own facts, costs and venue. A checklist helps the pool ask the same questions every time, so nothing big is missed.
When should a pool start asking these questions?
Early, before discovery closes. If a question shows a gap in the record, counsel still has time to look for the missing facts. Ask again just before mediation to see what changed.
Who makes the call?
The pool and its defense counsel. Outside tools and studies can add facts and a view of the local jury. They do not make the decision.