Start VerdictLine with one case that has a decision coming: a trial, a request for settlement authority, a special meeting or a pre-trial report. That is the best place to test a new way of reading cases. On a case like that, a pool may already spend on jury work or extra counsel hours. After the date, you can check the read against what happened. And the bills on that case show clearly what the work cost.
Why start with a case that has a date coming?
A case with a date coming is where the stakes are highest and the questions are sharpest. Will it settle, or will it go to a jury? If it goes, how will jurors in that county see it? Some pools spend on these questions through jury consultants, mock trials or extra counsel hours. Many spend nothing, and decide without a view of the local jury.
Trial costs add up, too. A 2016 PRIMA conference session listed attorney fees, expert fees and "your staff time participating in the trial" as costs to weigh before trying a case (Safety National's notes on the session).
A dated decision also gives a clear check. After the trial, the mediation or the board meeting, you can put our read beside what happened. For a plain list of what to weigh, see settle or try: questions a pool can ask.
What the pool gets on that case
VerdictLine works on the case from wherever it stands. It reads the record, cites every point to the page, and shows how a jury in that county is likely to see the case. As trial gets close, it adds daily transcript summaries and one study: a focus group, a venue study or a trial-week shadow jury. Counsel reviews and signs every report.
How do you check the read?
After the verdict, we write a review that shows how each main point of the read compared with what happened at trial. Each point keeps the date we wrote it. Misses are listed with the reasons, so you can see where the read went wrong and why. One verdict is one outcome, so we report every case, not only the ones that went well. See how we report proof.
What to measure
A test is only useful if you measure it. We suggest measuring three things on your own numbers, against past bills on similar cases:
- Counsel hours. Time spent reading records and drafting reports.
- Turnaround. How long it takes for a report to reach the pool after a deposition or filing.
- Corrections. How often a report has to go back for fixes.
Those numbers come from your bills and your files, not from us. That makes the result something you can take to your board. See how we check our reads, misses included.
How the first case is set up
The first case runs at a fixed fee, charged to that case. Before any work starts, we check with you who signs and what their limit is on that file. Nothing is needed from your claims administrator's systems. VerdictLine works from a copy of the record, and your files stay your permanent record. A public pool can pay per case to the claim file, through the monthly bill list, or under a yearly not-to-exceed amount.
What comes after the first case
If the first case works, the next step is a pilot. The pool picks its full book or a set of cases. We check in at 30, 60 and 90 days and measure the same numbers. If the pilot works, an annual agreement puts every new case through VerdictLine, set up through the process your pool chooses. See how VerdictLine works, stage by stage.
Want to see our work first?
You can ask for a free one-page read on one case first. You pick a case from the public record, and we send one page on how a jury in that county is likely to see it, and why. To see what you would be buying, read what VerdictLine is, or how a county jury read helps before you settle. If a mock jury is on the table, see mock jury research for public entities.
Common questions
Who signs for the first case?
It depends on your pool. Often it is the claims or litigation manager, the fund attorney or the general counsel, within their limit on that file. We check who signs and their limit with you first.
How can a public pool pay for it?
Per case to the claim file, through the monthly bill list, or under a yearly not-to-exceed amount. The pool picks the route that fits its rules.
What do we need from our claims administrator?
Nothing. VerdictLine works from a copy of the case record. The pool's files stay its permanent record.